Story Highlights

• Rodney Alcala, the “Dating Game Killer,” used his persona as a charming photographer to lure his victims.
• Convicted of murdering at least eight people, though authorities suspect he may have killed up to 130.
• Alcala appeared on The Dating Game in 1978, during his killing spree, and won the game, but the bachelorette refused to go on a date due to finding him “creepy.”
• He died of natural causes in 2021 while on death row, leaving behind countless cold cases linked to him through DNA evidence.

Rodney Alcala is one of the most notorious serial killers in American history, often referred to as the “Dating Game Killer” due to his infamous appearance on the television show The Dating Game in 1978. He lived a double life—one as a charming, seemingly normal man who captivated audiences on national television, and the other as a remorseless murderer who preyed on women and children. Despite his death in 2021, his legacy of terror endures as investigators continue to piece together the extent of his crimes.

Who Was Rodney Alcala?

Rodney James Alcala, born Rodrigo Jacques Alcala-Buquor in 1943, was a notorious serial killer and sex offender. While convicted for five murders in California, he is suspected of killing as many as 130 people across the United States. His crimes were known for their sadistic nature, as Alcala often toyed with his victims, strangling and reviving them multiple times before finally killing them.

Alcala posed as a professional photographer, using his charm to lure women and young girls into trusting him. His victims were often photographed, with many explicit images found in his possession after his arrest. Despite his dark activities, he managed to appear on the TV show The Dating Game in 1978, winning the contest, though the bachelorette later refused to date him, finding him unsettling.

Alcala was sentenced to death in California, though he also pleaded guilty to two murders in New York. He died in prison in 2021, but the true number of his victims may never be fully known. His story remains a chilling reminder of how charm and manipulation can hide true evil.

Why Is Rodney Alcala Called the Dating Game Killer?

Rodney Alcala earned his notorious nickname after appearing on the popular TV show The Dating Game in 1978, while he was still actively committing murders. The show featured a bachelorette who asked three “eligible bachelors” questions to determine which one she would go on a date with. Alcala, bachelor number one, won the game by charming the audience and the bachelorette, Cheryl Bradshaw, who later refused to go on the date due to finding him “creepy.”

Bradshaw’s rejection might have further triggered Alcala’s already twisted mind. What makes his appearance on the show especially chilling is that he had already murdered several women before stepping onto that stage.

How Did Rodney Alcala Manage to Evade Capture for So Long?

Rodney Alcala’s ability to evade capture for years is one of the most disturbing aspects of his story. Alcala’s charm, intelligence, and skill as a photographer allowed him to lure victims without suspicion. He was also adept at using false identities, which helped him flee from California to New York when the police were after him for the rape and attempted murder of Tali Shapiro, an eight-year-old girl in 1968.

Using the alias John Berger, Alcala enrolled at New York University and studied film under Roman Polanski. During this time, he continued to attack women, further masking his true nature behind his role as a photographer. His background in photography, combined with his good looks and intelligence, allowed him to fly under the radar for years.

Alcala’s criminal record was another factor that made his capture more complicated. He had already been arrested for multiple assaults but was often released on parole after serving minimal time. The criminal justice system’s failure to keep him incarcerated for his early crimes allowed him to continue his spree across multiple states.

How Many People Did Rodney Alcala Kill?

While Rodney Alcala was convicted of murdering eight people, authorities believe the actual number could be much higher, potentially up to 130 victims. The exact number remains unknown due to the nomadic lifestyle Alcala led and the vast geographic range of his crimes, which spanned California, New York, Wyoming, and other states.

His victims were primarily women, although police have found photographs of both men and boys among his possessions. Investigators have connected him to cold cases using DNA evidence, but there are still many unidentified victims.

What Happened on The Dating Game?

Rodney Alcala’s appearance on The Dating Game remains one of the most bizarre elements of his criminal history. His unsettling behavior on the show, which many saw as playful at the time, now looks far more sinister. When the bachelorette, Cheryl Bradshaw, asked Alcala to describe himself, he responded, “I’m called the banana, and I look good.” He followed up this odd remark by telling her to “peel me,” a comment that drew laughter from the audience.

What’s chilling in hindsight is how Alcala’s comments reflect his twisted psyche. Despite the audience laughing, Bradshaw had an intuition that something wasn’t right. She later told the show’s producers that she felt deeply uncomfortable around him and refused to go on the date. This rejection, as some criminal profilers suggest, might have exacerbated Alcala’s violent tendencies.

What Were Rodney Alcala’s Tactics?

Alcala’s modus operandi was particularly sadistic. He would often strangle his victims until they lost consciousness, only to revive them and repeat the process multiple times before finally killing them. His cruelty was enhanced by his tendency to pose his victims after their deaths, a behavior often seen in serial killers with extreme narcissism and sadistic tendencies.

One of the scariest aspects of Alcala’s methods was his use of photography. He approached women and young girls, offering to take their pictures for his “portfolio.” Many trusted him due to his professional appearance, only to fall into his trap. Some of his photographs were later used as evidence to identify his victims, but many remain unidentified, raising questions about the true extent of his crimes.

How Did Rodney Alcala Die?

Rodney Alcala died on July 24, 2021, from natural causes while awaiting execution on California’s death row. At the time of his death, he had been sentenced to death for the murders of five women and had been connected to three others through DNA. Despite his death, authorities continue to investigate his links to numerous unsolved cases across the United States.

How Did Rodney Alcala’s Crimes Impact Law Enforcement?

Rodney Alcala’s case highlighted the deficiencies in the criminal justice system and how easily dangerous individuals could slip through the cracks. His ability to evade capture after being convicted of lesser crimes, only to be released on parole, allowed him to continue his killing spree.

Additionally, Alcala’s use of false identities and his tendency to move from state to state made it difficult for law enforcement agencies to track him. Today, thanks to DNA technology and more stringent background checks, many of the lapses that allowed Alcala to operate for so long would be less likely to happen.

What Is the Legacy of Rodney Alcala?

Rodney Alcala’s story serves as a chilling reminder of the duality of human nature—how a person can present one face to the world while hiding a dark and terrifying secret. His case also underscores the importance of improved background checks, especially for individuals working with vulnerable populations, such as photographers and teachers.

His appearance on The Dating Game remains a haunting example of how predators can hide in plain sight, even on national television. Today, Alcala’s crimes continue to captivate the public’s imagination, and filmmakers and writers are still drawn to his story, such as Netflix’s upcoming release of Woman of the Hour, which dramatizes his dating game appearance and crimes​

Conclusion

Rodney Alcala’s life and crimes are a chilling testament to the horrors that can lurk beneath the surface of charm and charisma. As new victims are discovered and the true scale of his killings comes to light, his legacy remains one of the most terrifying in American criminal history. His story raises unsettling questions about trust, intuition, and the criminal justice system’s role in protecting society from predators like him.

Let his story serve as a reminder that evil can often hide in the most unexpected places, and vigilance is key to ensuring that justice is served for victims who may never be fully identified.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Why is Rodney Alcala called the “Dating Game Killer”?
Rodney Alcala is called the “Dating Game Killer” because he appeared on the TV show The Dating Game in 1978, during his murder spree. Despite winning the contest, the bachelorette refused to date him after finding him “creepy.” He had already committed multiple murders by the time of his appearance on the show.

2. How did Rodney Alcala evade capture for so long?
Alcala used aliases and moved between states to avoid detection. His charm and his job as a photographer helped him lure victims without raising suspicion. Law enforcement struggled to connect his crimes across different states, which allowed him to continue killing for years.

3. How many people did Rodney Alcala kill?
While Alcala was convicted of eight murders, investigators believe he could be responsible for as many as 130 deaths. His extensive collection of photographs has led authorities to believe many more victims remain unidentified.

4. What happened to Cheryl Bradshaw after the Dating Game?
Cheryl Bradshaw, the bachelorette who picked Alcala on The Dating Game, sensed something was off about him and refused to go on the date. She later revealed that she felt “creepy vibes” from him, a decision that potentially saved her life.

5. How did Rodney Alcala lure his victims?
Alcala posed as a professional photographer, often approaching women and young girls with the promise of professional photo shoots. He would then lure them into secluded locations, where he would assault and murder them.

6. When did Rodney Alcala die?
Rodney Alcala died on July 24, 2021, of natural causes while on death row in California. Despite multiple death sentences, he never faced execution.

7. How was Rodney Alcala finally caught?
Alcala was arrested in 1979 after the murder of 12-year-old Robin Samsoe. Her friends had described a man taking pictures of them at the beach, and a police sketch led to Alcala’s arrest. Subsequent DNA evidence linked him to additional murders.

---

• Braised Halibut with Carrots and Coriander: A Weeknight Delight
• Understanding Supraspinatus Tendinopathy with Partial Thickness Tear: Symptoms, Treatment, and Recovery
• Stevia: Why You Should Always Read Labels on Keto-Friendly Products Carefully
• Erythritol: A Comprehensive Guide to the Pros and Cons of This Popular Sweetener
• Tasty- Yummy Tex-Mex Chicken and Rice